Provided
by the Association of Executive Search Consultants, www.aesc.org
Professional standards
and ethics
The mission of the Association
of Executive Search Consultants (AESC) is to establish and promote
the highest possible standards for the practice of retained executive
search.
The AESC has recently produced the Client's and Candidate's Bills
of Rights to better explain your rights and obligations when dealing
with executive search firms. We have also, under the direction of
a special Board committee, recently revised the Professional Practice
Guidelines, which, together with our Code of Ethics and Steps to
Effective Reference and Background Checking, lay the foundation
for the standards of the profession.
Introduction to the
Code of Ethics and Professional Practice Guidelines
The Association
of Executive Search Consultants (AESC) is the professional association
representing retained executive search consulting firms worldwide.
The AESC's mission is to promote the highest professional standards
in retained executive search, broaden public understanding of the
executive search process, and serve as an advocate for the interests
of its member firms.
Retained executive search consulting is a specialized form of senior-level
management consulting, conducted through an exclusive engagement.
Its purpose is to assist a client organization in defining executive
positions, then identifying and selecting well-qualified candidates
through comprehensive search processes.
Successful retained executive search is built upon relationships
rather than discrete transactions; it is widely recognized as an
indispensable service to organizations worldwide.
The AESC adopted a Code
of Ethics in 1977, which outlines the fundamental principles
that guide executive search consultants in performing their duties
and conducting relationships with client and candidate communities.
In 1984 the AESC also developed a set of Professional Practice
Guidelines. These represent the AESC's view of contemporary best
practices and exemplify the standards of professionalism expected
of executive search consultants.
In 2002 the Professional Practice Guidelines were reviewed and
updated to provide clearer interpretation and guidance to member
firms, their clients and candidates.
The AESC and its member firms recognize that the reputation of the
executive search profession rests upon the quality and integrity
of relationships with clients, candidates, employees and the public.
Code of Ethics
The Association of Executive Search Consultants, Inc. (AESC) is
a worldwide association of retained executive search consulting
firms.
In order to perform their duties responsibly, AESC member firms
are guided by the following ethical principles.
AESC members will:
Professionalism: conduct their activities in a manner that reflects
favorably on the profession.
Integrity: conduct their business activities with integrity
and avoid conduct that is deceptive or misleading.
Competence: perform all search consulting assignments competently,
and with an appropriate degree of knowledge, thoroughness and urgency.
Objectivity: exercise objective and impartial judgment in
each search consulting assignment, giving due consideration to all
relevant facts.
Accuracy: strive to be accurate in all communications with
clients and candidates and encourage them to exchange relevant and
accurate information.
Conflicts of Interest: avoid, or resolve through disclosure
and waiver, conflicts of interest.
Confidentiality: respect confidential information entrusted
to them by clients and candidates.
Loyalty: serve their clients loyally and protect client interests
when performing assignments.
Equal Opportunity: support equal opportunity in employment
and objectively evaluate all qualified candidates.
Public Interest: conduct their activities with respect for
the public interest.
The Client’s Bill
of Rights
April 2001
An executive search involves a complex process that requires a substantial
investment of your time and resources. When you hire a retained
executive search firm, youre entitled to receive a high level
of service. But what is the difference between a professional, reliable
service and a lower quality of service? What are your rights and
obligations as a client? Above all, how do you know when you have
received excellence in client service?
Search firms will answer most -- but not all -- of these questions
in the consulting contract. Therefore, the more you know about the
ins and outs of working with search firms, the better your chances
of achieving a successful search and receiving full value for your
investment. In the belief that well-educated clients always lead
to better client/consultant relationships, the Association
of Executive Search Consultants (AESC) offers the following
"Clients Bill of Rights."
| I. |
The executive search firm shall provide you with an accurate
and candid assessment of its capabilities to perform your
search.
Not all search firms offer the same services, but they should
all operate in line with the highest professional standards.
In addition to the obvious differences in size and manpower,
search firms also vary in their areas of expertise, their
knowledge of and contacts within various industries, and the
skills and experience levels of their search consultants.
Before agreeing to undertake any search, the executive search
consulting firm should:
Verify that it has the resources, time, knowledge and expertise
to handle your specific assignment.
Disclose any and all information with regard to relationships
or circumstances that might create actual or potential conflicts
of interest. Disclose limitations arising through service
with other clients that may affect its ability to perform
the search assignment.
Define with you which part of your organization is the "client"
(i.e. which subsidiary, division, department, etc.) and agree
upon the period, if any, during which the firm will not recruit
from the defined client organization.
Define the scope and character of the services to be provided
and the fees and expenses to be charged for the services rendered.
This requires that you provide a full and accurate description
of your organization, its business needs and culture, the
position to be filled, and your criteria for the ideal candidate.
If the search firm cannot handle your assignment, it should
explain why and then refer you to another firm better equipped
to meet your needs.
|
| II. |
The executive search firm shall tell you who will conduct
the search.
In addition to the consultant who generates the business relationship,
there may be a team of professionals who will handle the search
assignment.
It is certainly within your rights to ask for and to receive
full and open disclosure regarding the consultants and their
ability to successfully handle the assignment, as well as
the resources the firm has available to support the consultant/team
working on your project.
|
| III. |
The executive search firm shall provide a high-level consultative
relationship.
"Retained executive search consulting" is defined
as a specialized form of management consulting, conducted
through an exclusive engagement and on a pre-determined retainer-fee
basis. Its purpose is to assist your organization in defining
executive positions, identifying well-qualified and motivated
candidates, and selecting those best suited through comprehensive,
quality assured search processes.
In addition to locating high quality candidates, your search
firm should also provide information and feedback that not
only helps direct your search for executive talent but can
also be used to run your business more effectively. This feedback
includes:
Knowledge of the industry in which the search will be conducted,
including availability of candidates, comparative assessments
of those candidates, and remuneration levels.
General market research regarding how your organization is
perceived in the market, what your competitors are doing,
and what kind of recruiting strategies may or may not be working
at any given point in time.
Do not expect a 50-page market research report for your retainer
fee. But the search firm should give you a reasonable overview
of market conditions and the general perception of your organization
in the marketplace for talent .
|
| IV. |
The executive search firm shall hold your information in
strict confidentiality.
By its very nature, an executive search requires you to divulge
highly sensitive information about your organization. The
search consultant must treat any and all information you give
them with the utmost confidentiality .
At the same time, the consultant cannot conduct an effective
search without making some information available to potential
candidates. To protect your interests, however, the search
consultant should guarantee that he or she will:
Use confidential client information only for the purposes
of conducting the assignment.
Disclose client information only to others within the search
firm (who may be supporting the consultant on this assignment)
or potential candidates who have a need to know the information.
Never use confidential information for personal gain or provide
that information to third parties for their personal gain.
|
| V. |
The executive search firm shall demonstrate a clear understanding
of the position, the company and the objectives of the search.
In order to conduct a successful search, the consultant must
have a crystal clear understanding of the position to be filled,
the requirements of the job and your company's culture. Accordingly,
you should insist on receiving a report that details the consultant's
understanding of :
- Your desired level and type of experience
- The background, education and technical skills needed
to successfully perform the position
- Responsibilities of the position
- Any interpersonal skills needed
Good search firms will do more than just feed back the job
description you present them. They will proactively help you
develop, modify and refine your own understanding of the position.
To help with this critical step, give your search consultant
access to all those who participate in the selection process
and encourage them to provide full disclosure regarding the
position to be filled.
Because the job description represents the bedrock of a successful
search, you have a reciprocal obligation to notify the consultant
any time circumstances (either internal or external) require
a change in the position or the type of person you're looking
for. Be aware that a major change in search specifications
may require a change in fees.
|
| VI. |
The executive search firm shall provide you with regular,
detailed status reports on the progress of the search.
Depending on the position to be filled, the availability of
talent and a host of other factors, a successful search can
take anywhere from a few weeks to several months. To keep
you up-to-date, the search firm should provide ongoing progress
reports that include:
- The companies at which the consultant has tried to target
candidates
- The market response to the search
- Obstacles to identifying or attracting candidates
- Candidates currently being developed
The search firm should update you regularly, either by phone,
fax, e-mail, written report or some combination of all four.
Let your consultant know your preferences.
|
| VII. |
The executive search firm shall present qualified candidates
who fit the position and the culture of your organization.
The consultant should present you with a range of qualified
potential candidates, whom he or she has thoroughly assessed
and interviewed. The consultant should be able to discuss
each candidate's:
- Experience level and significant achievements relative to
the position to be filled
- Education and background
- Intellectual, interpersonal and motivation competencies
- Personal strengths and weaknesses with respect to the position
to be filled
- Perceived cultural fit
- Interest in the position
- Remuneration and financial expectations
In presenting candidates, either individually or in a "shortlist,"
you should expect the consultant to discuss the interviewing
arrangements and other issues that can affect the critical
interviewing process. Immediately after you have interviewed
candidates, your search consultant should solicit your comments
and feedback and help you conduct comparative candidate assessment
and analysis. They should complete and transmit to you the
verification of credentials and reference checks.
If it becomes apparent that the search will take considerably
longer than expected or that it may not yield an acceptable
range of candidates, the consultant should inform you as soon
as possible and discuss alternative courses of action.
|
| VIII. |
The executive search firm shall help you negotiate with the
final candidate, representing both parties with skill, integrity
and a high degree of professionalism.
Once you have selected a final candidate, the consultant's
role changes from that of search agent to negotiator and communicator.
At this point, the consultant's primary function is to help
you bring the candidate on board in a manner that facilitates
a long and successful stay with your organization. This includes:
- Acting as an intermediary between you and the candidate
regarding compensation, benefits and other conditions of
employment.
- Feeding back to you any reservations or concerns the candidate
may have about accepting the position.
- Helping the candidate to assess the opportunity
- Working with both sides to create a "win" for
everyone
Although the consultant represents your interests first and
foremost, he or she must also remain sensitive to the needs
and concerns of the candidate. To do otherwise significantly
reduces the chances of a successful hire. In addition, representing
both parties with integrity and professionalism ensures two
important outcomes:
The candidate comes aboard feeling that he or she has been
treated fairly
The search enhances your company's reputation in the marketplace
Remember that your candidates are also very busy professionals
who have sacrificed valuable time to talk with you. Furthermore,
they did not solicit this opportunity; it was presented to
them.
|
| IX. |
The executive search firm shall provide you with a clear
understanding of its replacement policy and other unusual
situations that may arise during and after the search.
The search firm cannot (and should not be expected to) guarantee
to fill your position. The consultant also cannot guarantee
that, once placed, a new hire will stay with your firm. With
that in mind, the consultant should provide (in writing) an
explanation of the firm's policy regarding possible outcomes.
These include:
- The search firm's obligations and responsibilities to
you should a newly recruited professional leave your company
for any reason within an agreed period of time.
- Your obligations to the search firm should you hire a
candidate presented during the current engagement for a
position other than the assigned vacancy.
- The conditions under which the search firm can withdraw
from your assignment or consider it sufficiently changed
to start a new search.
|
| X. |
The executive search firm shall provide
you with a reasonable level of follow-through after you have
hired the candidate.
Seemingly successful placements can sometimes fall apart during
the transition period. As a result, the consultant's responsibility
does not end when the candidate accepts the offer. Instead,
the consultant should stay in contact with the new hire as long
as necessary to ensure a smooth transition and help them settle
into the new position. Above all, the consultant should make
sure that you are fully satisfied before considering the search
a success and concluding the assignment. |
Stand up for Your Rights!
Given the importance to your organization of filling the position
with the highest quality candidate, you have every right to expect
the highest level of service. Remember that by working with a retained
executive search firm you have entered into a consulting partnership.
Take a proactive approach to managing the relationship. Do your
homework and provide full and accurate information regarding the
position and the ideal candidate. Set very clear expectations up
front in terms of how you and the search consultant will work together.
Keep the lines of communication open on your end, and stay in regular
contact with your consultant until the assignment has been completed
to everyones satisfaction.
If at any time during the search your consultant doesnt seem
to understand the nature of the assignment, fails to provide ongoing
feedback and progress reports, fails to present a range of qualified
candidates or doesnt represent your firm in the manner you
wish, express your dissatisfaction immediately! Now that you know
your rights, its up to you to hold your search firm to the
high standard of service that you expect.
The Candidates’
Bill of Rights
July 2001
It often happens when you least expect it. Out of the blue you
receive a call from an executive search firm, wanting to know if
you might have an interest in a position they are trying to fill
for a client.
The opportunity seems promising, but you do not know what to expect.
What does the process entail? How long will it take? What will the
search firm expect from you? Most important, what are your rights
and obligations during the process? As a potential search candidate,
you are entitled to ask these questions and to have them answered.
In retained executive search, consultants endeavor to provide qualified
candidates for clients who wish to fill senior-level positions.
Although contractual obligations exist only between the search firm
and client, search consultants also build professional and ethical
relationships with candidates, whom they may remain in contact with
over a period of years.
Members of the Association
of Executive Search Consultants (AESC), the worldwide professional
organization for retained executive search firms, subscribe to a
code of ethics that states that these relationships should be characterized
by honesty, objectivity, accuracy and respect for confidentiality.
Strict adherence to this code is a requirement for all AESC members,
who must also abide by all data privacy laws applicable within their
country.
Furthermore, AESC members believe that the most successful executive
searches involve a three-way partnership, whereby the candidate,
the search firm and the client fully understand their rights, duties
and obligations to each other during the search process. As such,
we believe that all search candidates have a right to:
I. Confidentiality
When you become an executive search candidate, you put yourself
at a certain amount of risk with your current employer. For that
reason, you are entitled to the highest levels of confidentiality
from the search firm and the client organization. To safeguard your
confidentiality, the search consultant should:
Following a meeting to discuss your candidacy, obtain your authorization
before submitting your name and a report on you to the client organization.
Upon your request, contact you directly rather than through your
assistant or anyone else in your current company.
Not contact references provided by you without your permission.
Not discuss your potential candidacy with anyone outside the search
firm, and ensure that all employees of the firm abide by the same
rules.
Caution the client to also safeguard your confidentiality.
It is important to remember that you do not become a search candidate
until the consultant has conducted an initial evaluation of your
suitability for the position and you have expressed an interest
in it. If either of these two criteria are missing, you cannot be
considered a candidate for the position. However, even if the position
about which you are being contacted is not right for you at the
present time, you may still benefit from conversations with search
consultants by being kept up to date with the market for your skills
and experience. Candidates not selected on one search may be selected
on another.
II. Full Disclosure
In order to make the right decision, you need to know as much as
possible about the search firm you are talking to, the position
and the client organization. This ultimately requires full and open
disclosure regarding:
The nature and requirements of the position
The compensation package
Whether relocation is required
Pertinent information regarding the client organization
Be aware, however, that during your first conversation, when you
are still being evaluated as a potential candidate for the position,
the search consultant is under no obligation to divulge confidential
information about the position or the client. Only after you have
been identified as a legitimate candidate should you expect the
consultant to disclose more than the most basic information. Even
then, there are times when certain information about the client
must remain confidential until the final stages of the search process.
The search consultant should also make clear whether he or she
has been retained by the client to manage the appointment in question.
Retained executive search consultants work under an exclusive contract
with the client organization; and thus have not only confidential
access to the client on that assignment but have their full and
committed attention. If the consultant fails to notify you of this
important fact, do not hesitate to ask.
III. Timely Communication
The completion of an executive search assignment can often take
several months, with many steps between initial contact and the
ultimate hiring of the successful candidate. Once you become an
active candidate, the search firm should communicate with you in
a timely manner at each and every step of the process. This means
proactively updating you on the progress of the search as well as
responding in a timely manner to any inquiries initiated by you.
IV. Feedback
Based on his or her understanding of the position and the client's
needs, the search consultant should give you an honest appraisal
of where you seem to fit the opportunity and where you do not seem
to fit. If at any point in the process the client decides not to
proceed with your candidacy, the consultant should provide as complete
an explanation of the client's decision as possible.
V. Professional Treatment
Search consultants are expected to comply with all the employment
laws that apply to the normal hiring process. In addition, they
should also demonstrate a high level of professionalism with each
and every candidate. Professional treatment means that the search
consultant:
- Has a clear understanding of the position and the client's expectations
for it.
- Conducts an organized, well thought-out interview.
- Shows up on time and well-prepared for all appointments.
- Demonstrates in-depth knowledge of the market and the client.
- Answers all your questions in an honest and forthright manner.
VI. Adequate Process Details
As a search candidate, you are entitled to know what to expect
as the process unfolds. For example, what is the anticipated time
frame for the first round of interviews? If you make the first cut,
what happens next? Most search consultants will readily volunteer
this kind of information. If they do not, make a point to ask. In
particular, be prepared at any stage in the proceedings to ask:
- How long will this take?
- Who do I have to meet with before a decision is made?
- What time frame is the client working on?
- What is the next step?
VII. Respect for Your Time and Position
The search consultant understands that, as a senior level executive,
your current position demands your full time and attention. When
scheduling appointments and interviews, the search consultant and
the client should demonstrate the utmost respect for your time,
your position and your responsibilities to your employer.
VIII. Consistency Between the Search Firm and Their Client
The search consultant and the client should always do their best
to be on the same wavelength in terms of the information they present
to you. Keep in mind, however, that while the search consultant
represents the client organization, they do not have complete control
over the client's communication with you during the process. If
changes occur that contradict the information given to you by the
consultant, you should ask for clarification.
IX. No Pressure
The best executive search placements happen when the candidate
has the time to make a measured, well-thought out decision. For
this reason, the search consultant should never try to hurry your
decision or put undue pressure on you to accept an offer. However,
the consultant should keep you informed of any deadlines imposed
by the client and the implications for not making a decision prior
to those deadlines.
X. A Trusting Relationship
If the search consultant conducts him or herself in a manner befitting
these guiding principles, you should naturally develop an open and
trusting relationship. Conversely, if for any reason you do not
feel you can trust the search consultant or the client, you would
be well served to withdraw from the process. Keep in mind that the
best search consultants strive for more than just filling the position
for their client; they want to help you make the best decision for
you, your family and your career.
Concluding the Search
If the client decides to hire you to fill the position, you have
arrived at one of the most important stages of the search process:
negotiation of your employment agreement. This can involve highly
sensitive issues in which the search consultant can play a crucial
role of intermediary to ensure open and effective communication
between client and candidate. Use this 'honest broker' channel of
communication to candidly express any concerns or special requirements
that you may have on terms and conditions.
When the search process is completed and you have signed on the
dotted line, some search consultants will stay in touch with you
for three to six months to make sure that your transition into the
new position is a success. Feel free to contact your consultant
with major concerns that arise. He or she may well be able to help
sort out problems, and diplomatic intervention by the search consultant
will normally not be resented by the client. However, search consultants
are not professional coaches, and thus their role here may be limited.
If your candidacy does not result in a hire, most consultants will
want to keep you in their pool of candidates for future assignments.
They may contact you from time to time to maintain the relationship
and keep you appraised of any upcoming assignments. They may also
use you as a resource to help identify candidates for assignments
that are not a good fit for you. If you developed a good relationship
with the search consultant, you may want to take your own steps
to maintain the relationship as well.
Regardless of the outcome of the search, the consultant may not
use your name or the results of the search as testimonials without
your permission.
Putting Your Best Foot Forward
The executive search process is not a one-way street. Although
you have a right to expect courteous, professional treatment from
the search consultant and the client, there are a number of things
you can do to facilitate the process and advance your standing.
Be honest. Under no circumstances should you inflate your resume,
misrepresent your work history or "hold some cards back."
Also, be genuine about your interest (or lack of) in the position.
Complete and accurate disclosure by the candidate is an essential
element in the search process.
Be flexible. Make every effort to fit appointments and interviews
within your schedule.
Educate yourself. Conduct your own due diligence on the search
firm and the client organization, and understand the unique value
of retained executive search consulting.
Have realistic expectations. Understand that the process takes
time and that you will be one of several qualified candidates.
Negotiate in good faith. Do not lead search consultants to believe
you are negotiating only with them if you are considering offers
from more than one organization.
Above all, do not think you have a "done deal" just because
you develop a close relationship with the search consultant. Remember
that the consultant's job is to present several qualified candidates
to the client, and it is the client who makes the ultimate decision.
Making the Connection
How do you get on the "radar screen" of leading search
firms around the world? One of the best ways is to register with
Blue Steps, a service of the Association of Executive Search Consultants.
Doing so will raise your visibility with the most appropriate search
firms in an efficient, economical and confidential manner. It will
also ensure that any search firms who contact you from the BlueSteps
global database subscribe to the highest ethics and standards as
put forth by the AESC.
The more you know about the executive search process, the better
you can position yourself should you become an executive search
candidate. In the meantime, remember that the most successful executive
searches involve those where you, the search consultant and the
client know your rights and obligations within the search process
and adhere to the highest standards of professional and ethical
conduct.
|